New Tool Aims to Stop ALS Diagnosis Delays

SAVANNAH, Georgia — A new clinical education tool aims to speed the diagnosis of amyotrophic lateral sclerosis (ALS), which often goes undetected for months even in neurologist offices.
The one-page “thinkALS” tool, designed for clinicians who don’t specialize in neuromuscular disorders, offers a guide to recognize ALS symptoms and determine when it’s time to refer patients to ALS clinics.
“Time is of the essence. It’s really important because the paradigm of looking at ALS is shifting from this being a fatal disease that nobody can do anything about,” said Suma Babu, MBBS, MPH, assistant professor of neurology at Massachusetts General Hospital/Harvard Medical School in Boston, in a presentation at American Association of Neuromuscular & Electrodiagnostic Medicine (AANEM) 2024. “As a community, we need to think about how can get to the diagnosis point early and get patients started on therapies.”
On Average, ALS Diagnosis Takes 12-15 Months
As Babu noted, the percentage of patients initially diagnosed with something else may be as high as 52%. The time to diagnosis in ALS remained steady at a mean 12-15 months from 1996-1998 to 2000-2018.
“If you keep in mind that an average ALS patient lives only 3-5 years from symptom onset, they’re spending one third of their survival time in just trying to figure out what the diagnosis is,” Babu said. “Often, they may even undergo unnecessary testing and unnecessary surgeries — carpal tunnel releases, spinal surgeries, and so on.”
Babu’s own research, which is under review for publication, examined 2011-2021 Medicare claims to determine the typical time from first neurologist consult to confirmed ALS diagnosis. The mean for ALS/neuromuscular specialists is 9.6 months, while it’s 16.7 months for nonspecialist neurologists.
“It’s a hard pill to swallow,” Babu said, referring to the fact that neurologists are contributing to some of this situation. “But it is a challenge because ALS does not have a definitive diagnostic test, and you’re ruling out other possibilities.”
A ‘Sense of Nihilism’ About Prognoses
She added that “unless you’re seeing a lot of ALS patients, this is not going to be on a neurologist’s or a nurse practitioner’s radar to think about ALS early and then refer them to the right place.”
There’s also an unwarranted “sense of nihilism” about prognoses for patients, she said. “Sometimes people do not understand what’s going on within the ALS field in terms of ‘What are we going to do about it if it’s diagnosed?’”
The new one-page tool will be helpful in making diagnoses, she said. “If you have a patient who has asymmetric, progressive weakness, there is an instrument you can turn to that will walk you through the most common symptoms. It’ll also walk you through what to do next.”
The tool lists features of ALS and factors that support — or don’t support — an ALS diagnosis. Users are told to “think ALS” if features in two categories are present and no features in a third category are present.
Referral Wording Is Crucial
Babu added that the “important key feature of this instrument” is guidance for non-neurologists regarding what to write on a referral to neurology so the patient is channeled directly to an ALS clinic. The recommended wording: “CLINICAL SUSPICION FOR ALS.”
Neurologist Ximena Arcila-Londono, MD, of Henry Ford Health in Detroit, spoke after Babu’s presentation and agreed that wording is crucial in referrals. “Please include in your words ‘Rule out motor neuron disorder’ or ‘Rule out ALS,’” she said. “Some people in the community are very reluctant to use those words in their referral. If you don’t use the referral and you send them [regarding] weakness, that person is going to get stuck in the general neurology pile. The moment you use the word ‘motor neuron disorder’ or ALS, most of us will get to those patients within a month.”
The tool’s wording adds that “most ALS centers can accommodate urgent ALS referrals within 2 weeks.”
Babu disclosed receiving research funding from the AANEM Foundation, American Academy of Neurology, Muscular Dystrophy Association, OrphAI, Biogen, Ionis, Novartis, Denali, uniQure, and MarvelBiome. Arcila-Londono had no disclosures.
 
Send comments and news tips to [email protected].